Tuesday, March 13, 2007

New York Press Review: "The Wayward Cloud"

From the very beginning of his confused review Armond White reveals he has no idea how to process the bizarre, provocative experience of Tsai Ming-liang's The Wayward Cloud. First off, he calls it a "porno musical," a misleading term since the film is a musical about pornography -- its participants, its viewers, and the society it influences with its images -- and not a musical featuring actual pornographic material. Then in the second paragraph he offers a series of contradictory statements:

These [musical] numbers occur in unexpected contrast to the humdrum dailiness that is Tsai's specialty. He introduces his characters as they wander the gray, dull, bizarrely empty city; sometimes walking past each other without recognition—almost refusing to communicate. This reticence is the exact opposite of what movie musicals are about.

Characters acting out fantasies in lavish musical numbers that allow them to express what they cannot in their boring, quotidian existences? Sounds in line with a particular strand of the traditional movie musical to us. But maybe we should wait for AW to explain what he means:

When Tsai follows this dysfunctional union with musical numbers, it demonstrates a changed perspective on human relations. Today, even the romantic fantasies of typical movie musicals are infected with pessimism. The Wayward Cloud isn't a deconstructed musical like the great postmodern Pennies from Heaven. Instead, Tsai reconstructs a classical genre to match the desperation of an era that has rejected musicals' implicit outworn utopianism. For some viewers this depersonalization will make Tsai's vision seem new, perhaps even radical, rather than simply depressive. But it's a coherent vision and unafraid of emotional affect. Tsai dramatizes a new approach to anomie. Linking private sexual thoughts is his way of giving shape to a pervasive loneliness.

Very, very odd. Initially White believes that Tsai "demonstrates a changed perspective on human relations." Then, all of a sudden, he doesn't, an idea implied in White's rejection of others' collective misperception of the film: "For some viewers this depersonalization will make Tsai's vision seem new, perhaps even radical, rather than simply depressive." But then, faster than you can say "muddled," Tsai's vision is new again: "Tsai dramatizes a new approach to anomie."
What in the name of watermelon fucking is going on here? Armond's flying contradictions might very well be unconsciously perpetrated, but judging by the next paragraph, they very well might not. After foolishly drawing a comparison between The Wayward Cloud and Three Times (why, because they're both directed by Asian art cinema faves? If so, that's a pretty weak link), White finally expresses his ambivalence about the film in direct terms, calling it "a self-conscious musical about dislocation -- an, at times ingenious, at times, enervating [sic] variation on Tsai's usual unhappy theme."
But why the reservations? Again the comparison to Hou Hsaio-Hsien's empty formalism, and thus this:

Unfortunately, after the heightened emotional quality of Tsai's musical numbers, he also retreats to distanced long shots and detached framing held so long it drains your involvement. The Wayward Cloud culminates in a marathon copulation scene that unites the three protagonists in desolate joylessness. It cannot be the fault of decadent western pop but of Tsai's own preference for pseudo-profundity. His anti-musical is, finally, equivalent to joyless sex.

"Pseudo-profundity"? That's it? That's all White can come up with in his criticism of the film's shortcomings (pun totally intended)? Can we at least get some reasons for this pseudo-profundity more substantial than "distanced long shots and detached framing held so long it drains your involvement"? (Waaaaaah, Armond's bored; Waaaaaah, Armond needs his fix of Hollywood "pop.")
Look, The Wayward Cloud is a difficult film. It's at once silly, beautiful, disgusting, obvious, moralizing, beyond moralizing, and frustrating. And it is most definitely challenging. One can either decline that challenge, as did Nathan Lee of The Village Voice in his (as usual) dismissive review, or accept it, as did David Wilentz of The Brooklyn Rail. Or one can, as did Armond, give equal consideration to the film's failures and successes. If choosing this last route one must be especially clear in describing one's mixed feelings about the film, as well as proving the ability to back up those feelings with insightful analyses and ideas that carefully weigh pros and cons. But Armond's review of The Wayward Cloud is full of ambivalent feeling without much thought behind it. There's no insight in what he has communicated to his readers about this film, just flailing musings and halfhearted praises and disapprovals. Even when limning the film's basic themes and structures AW contradicts himself. "I liked this but not this," Armond seems to be saying, without venturing far enough into what Tsai's trying to do, where he goes right and where he goes wrong. "Pseudo-profundity" indeed.

16 comments:

1sam2 said...

You falling off the blog or what? blog more!

Sarah said...

Hello!

I know that this isn't exactly a comment, but I couldn't find your e-mail address, and I wanted to write and tell you about a new website for artists, musicians, fashion designers, and filmmakers: www.PutItOn.com. I've been using the site as an artist and have my work there, and am trying to support it because I believe in it. Basically, the site allows artists from all over the world to connect, display their portfolios, and sell their work (with NO commission taken!). The site gives artists a FREE gigabyte of space to showcase their portfolios, allows you to stream audio and video works, lets you create live personal broadcasts, and translates any writing into ten different languages. If you could take the time to visit the site, and if you like it too, let your readers know about it, and even sign up yourself or link to it on your site it would be greatly appreciated! We are trying to make a go of helping out artists everywhere and are trying to get the word out, so please help us out if you like the site after checking it out! Thank you!

All the best,
Sarah at PutItOn.com

John Demetry said...

Armond White has a new book out!

It’s titled KEEP MOVING: THE MICHAEL JACKSON CHRONICLES

http://www.resistanceworks.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!

Comedy Movies said...

Sounds like an ODD movie to watch

Contraceptive Pills said...

Nice Post...^^^
Tramadol to Buy l Tramadol to Buy l Cerazette l Cilest l Diane 35 l Gynera Contraceptive Pills l Meliane l Mercilon l Microgynon Contraceptive Pill l Yasmin Contraceptive l Eltroxin l Estrogen l Livial l Mesterolone l Norethisterone l Progynova 2mg l Eryacne l Stieva-A l Stieva-A l

Contraceptive Pills said...

Nice Post...^^^
Tramadol to Buy l Tramal 100mg l Tramal Retard l Tramadol to Buy l Tramacap l Tramadol to Buy l Tramadol to Buy l Washer and Dryers l Washingmachines l Haier Portable Washer l Whirlpool Cabrio Washing Machine l Whirlpool WFW9150WW l Contraceptive Pills l Cerazette l Cilest l Diane 35 l Emergency Contraceptive l Gynera Contraceptive Pills l Marvelon l Meliane l Mercilon l Microgynon Contraceptive Pill l Yasmin Contraceptive l Yaz Contraceptive Pills l Andriol l Androcur l Divigel l Eltroxin l Estrogen l Finasteride l Finasteride 5mg l Livial l Mesterolone l Metesto l Norethisterone l Oestrogel l Progynova 2mg l

Washer and Dryers said...

Nice Post...^^^
Acnotin l Acnotin l Clindamycin Phosphate l Eryacne l Isotrexin l Roaccutane l Stieva-A l Stieva-A l Stieva-A l Tramadol to Buy l Tramacap l Tramadol to Buy l Tramadol to Buy l Tramal Retard l NEUROBION l Neurobion Injection l Duofilm l Amoxicillin Capsules l Deanxit l Fluoxetine HCl l Hydroxyzine HCl l

www.toledo-3d.com said...

I think every person ought to read it.

Anonymous said...

Eli Manning Jersey axiotakix
Justin Smith Red Jersey axiotakix
Nike Brian Urlacher Jersey axiotakix
http://www.nikecowboysnflstore.com

Anonymous said...

When we finally glance at the specification of the phrase really like, not only in relation to its a romantic romance utilizing yet another, but like a feeling that may be engendered once you have miltchmonkey an improved association with yourself far too - or perhaps for a feeling of greater oneness household or even human race : that becomes a lot more crystal clear that all everyone wants in life will be love.

Anonymous said...

ï»?The LMSFinish indicates to the LMS that the user has ended the course and any further communication between the two will be rejectedtimestamp a > span {display: inline-block;width: 16px;background-image:url(http://imagesAlthough the new exam follows a multiple choice format#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] it is undeniably thorough in its range of questions A good speaker believes in what he is saying Ryan has famously had his views on black Americans attacked#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] particularly after being given a rather lousy 10% approval rating on civil rights by the NAACP#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] which was mentioned in another article by Goff Although a number of the larger members of this group were initially described as planets#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] in 2006 the International Astronomical Union reclassified Pluto and its largest neighbours as dwarf planets#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] leaving only eight planets in the Solar System
ï»?A Value Investor is unlikely to consider investing in a company that doesn’t generate good Free Cash FlowsThrough cheap software discounts#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] people can obtain computer programs that will help them find cheap#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] discounted travel opportunities that are available through Internet cruise ship companies Denis Leary ? Leary is probably best known for the FX show Rescue Me#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] which is now in its sixth season#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] but he's also a successful comedian#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] a somewhat successful movie star (although his choice of material has often been suspect)#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] and a published authorauthor {line-height: 20px;color: #333;font-family: Arial#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] Helvetica#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] sans-serif;} It may be looking at a corrupted files and software that is no longer working or on your computerOne such email or phone contact from what appears to be the legitimate group has contacted the Arctic Beacon and has provided what appears to be a wealth of inside information of the behind-the-scenes workings of how The Wanta Plan#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] as well as other monies#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] are being handled Miami - Patrick Surtain#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] CB Southern Mississippi 45

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.c-online-casino.co.uk/]uk casinos[/url] check the latest [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com/]casino bonus[/url] autonomous no store bonus at the foremost [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]spare casino games
[/url].

Anonymous said...

|
|
|

Anonymous said...

[url=http://longchampsacsa.blog.galeon.com/]sac longchamps[/url] Certain prescriptions and essential non-prescription medicines are permitted in sizes larger than 100 ml and are to be carried in your carry-on. These items include baby formula, milk, juice and baby food for traveling infants younger than 24 months. The Latest Mulberry Henry Overnight Natural Leather Briefcase Black for Men,Mulberry handbags from mulberry factory shop are on sale The items must be declared during security screening, removed from the carry-on and placed directly into the bin at the checkpoint..
[url=http://longchampsoldesa.postbit.com/]sacs longchamps[/url] Down-filled collar at top seals around the neck to prevent warm air from escaping and cold air from entering. Large draft tube located behind the zipper Mulberry Bags Outlet Online Shop is selling different styles of handbags with high quality. This item, Highly Appreciated Mulberry Women's East West Bayswater Leather Shoulder Black Bag, is suitable for women, men and youth. prevents warm air from escaping and cold air from entering. Interior fabric loops stabilize a sleeping bag liner, sold separately.
[url=http://sportsrantz.com/longchamppliagea/]sac longchamp[/url] Whether it is with an night time get together or perhaps with conventional situations just like marriage ceremonies, these kinds of look-alike bags can bring in self-assurance inside of an individual. You may believe that the physical appearance is the same as in which with the females which possess their particular authentic high-priced hand bags on the biceps and triceps. The products can be Buy soft leather Mulberry Women's Bayswater Leather Satchel Black Bag at auction has come to the stage of a pack quite a fantastic Single parent's Evening reward or perhaps strictly any expression regarding gratitude... Again handbags from brand like Louis Vuitton Greta, Prada shopping Tote, Chanel Metallic bag and Chanel zippered bag are the most popular choice among party goers. No doubt these brands will be expensive not making it possible for everyone to own one. In order to posses one youll have to wait till the stores put up sales which can get frustrating..

Anonymous said...


Warm up of Chinese male basket is big series of the Europe in getting the better of black hill to win surpasses make a good beginning
First half match, line of black mountain of 41-32 of Chinese male basket. Match of the second half, form of Wang Zhi Zhi Zhuang is good, left jump cast hit the target 2 minutes. Exterior line of Zhu Fang rain becomes angry hit the target 3 minutes, 46-32. Last night, wang Shipeng and Sun Yue stay leisurely next attendant chatting, look they are to won't enter the court the match. Breakthrough of Liu brighting left wing jumps cast hit the target, exterior line of Zhu Fang rain again in violent wind 3 minutes, 53-38. Chinese male basket adjusts tactics to adopt full-court press hard on, zhu Fang rain forces adversary error, the basket on [url=http://nikeshoesonsale.manifo.com/]nike shoes on sale[/url] secondary attack Chen Jianghua is procurable after be being grabbed, week roc exterior line moves to hit the target 3 minutes, chinese male basket precedes the advantage expands further. The sousaphone hits the target 2 minutes after Chen Jianghua shows the technology like variety to break through. The 3rd match, line of black mountain of 65-50 of Chinese male basket, enter last race.
Last match, both sides is attacked for many times not if really. Spell nearly of the both sides in grabbing to create conflict, su Wei be born and adversary are pushed, not bad the judgment parts both sides avoided conflict in time. The match still remains 7 minutes of 30 seconds, the way in Yili is wonderful the basket on the breakthrough is procurable, break notch barren, filling basket of backboard of the field before Wang Zhelin is grabbed is procurable, final, chinese male basket with line of 83 blacker than 55 conquer mountain, dual meet of male basket of the Europe in obtaining first match wins. (reporter sly brave)